21 November 2026

The Short Cut That Closed With the Department Store

99a The High Street, Ilfracombe
Photograph: Roger A Smith. Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 2.0

I tend to look at the side doors of an empty department store before I look at the main frontage. A building with entrances on two or three streets may once have been part of the way people crossed the centre. They went through it to avoid the rain, reach the bus stop or cut out a corner. When those doors are locked, the loss is not confined to shopping. A familiar route has disappeared.

That matters particularly on a November afternoon. The alternative may involve a narrow pavement beside a blank elevation, a service yard entrance and a longer wait at a crossing. None of these is necessarily a serious obstacle on its own. Together, they can make a journey less appealing, especially with a walking stick, a pushchair or heavy bags. The smaller shops along the old route inherit that inconvenience without having changed anything about their own businesses.

A route is not necessarily a right

I would be careful about calling the old passage a public route. Walking through a shop for years does not, by itself, establish a public right of way. It may simply have been something the retailer allowed during opening hours. Once trading stops, the owner has security, insurance and maintenance to consider. Keeping a door open is not a cost-free gesture, and an empty sales floor is not automatically a safe pedestrian passage.

Still, I think the routes through the building deserve attention before a new layout is settled. A plan can look convincing with a large letting on the ground floor and separate uses above, yet leave the surrounding streets less connected than before. The position of an entrance matters. So does whether it opens towards the quieter street or only towards the busiest frontage. Those decisions can influence where the next occupier's customers walk.

Acting for an occupier, I would want those arrangements pinned down rather than left as an attractive line on a drawing. Is access available throughout trading hours? Who controls the gates? Who pays for lighting, cleaning and repairs? Can the route be closed for works, and what alternative must be provided? A shop taking a lease beside a proposed passage needs to know whether it can actually rely on that passage being open.

Someone has to carry the cost

There is a temptation to describe a reopened route as an uncomplicated benefit. The bill makes it less simple. Creating a secure passage may require new walls, fire separation, accessible thresholds and changes to services. The lease must distinguish the owner's works from the tenant's fit-out, and the tenant's repairs from maintenance of shared areas. Otherwise, an apparently useful entrance can arrive with obligations that a small occupier cannot sensibly price.

I would also question a service charge that asks a handful of modest shops to support circulation space serving a much larger redevelopment. The allocation needs to reflect the lease terms and the facilities provided, not merely fill a gap in the owner's budget. A lower headline rent can be swallowed by shared costs. Nor would I advise a tenant to pay for hoped-for passing trade as though the people were already there.

Perhaps the old short cut cannot be restored. There may be level changes, security problems or a viable use that needs the whole floor. I would not dismiss that use simply because it fails to recreate the department store. But I would still walk the perimeter before accepting the proposal. An entrance moved a few yards, a better-lit corner or a shorter blank frontage may help. The building's next life will be experienced from the pavement as well as inside it.

Need advice on a lease renewal, rent review or dilapidations claim? chris@mcgarrigle.com

Translate website