20 November 2026
Who Answers the Phone After the Rental Auction

On a wet November afternoon, the practical test of a letting may be a phone call about water coming through the ceiling. Someone needs to answer, establish where it is coming from and arrange the appropriate work. That sounds a long way from high street rental auctions. I think it is close to their centre. Once the bidding and paperwork are over, an ordinary landlord-and-tenant relationship has to function, even where its beginnings were anything but ordinary.
In England, the auction power gives councils a route to bring certain persistently vacant commercial premises back into use. It is not available for every empty shop, and there are statutory tests and procedures before a letting can be imposed. I can see the value of that intervention. A street should not have to accept indefinite vacancy without question. But securing a tenant and establishing a workable relationship with the owner are different achievements.
The council is not the managing agent
An auction does not make the council the building’s owner or its everyday managing agent. That distinction needs to be understood by the incoming occupier. The authority may have been the most visible and responsive party throughout the process, while the landlord has remained distant. It would be quite natural for a trader to ring the council when something goes wrong. Natural, but not necessarily effective: the person receiving that call may have neither the contractual responsibility nor the authority to order a repair.
I would want the handover to identify the landlord’s contact, any managing agent, the route for reporting defects and the arrangements for urgent access. Those details matter in a small parade with flats above, shared drains or a roof spanning several units. A tenant cannot sensibly arrange work to somebody else’s part of the building just because rain is reaching their stock. Nor should an owner receive a vague complaint weeks after a problem first appeared. Clear reporting protects both sides.
The lease remains the starting point for deciding who must do what. Water entering a shop does not, by itself, tell us who owes the repairing obligation. The extent of the premises let, the repair wording, any condition limitation and the provisions for retained parts all matter. Having spent much of my working life on occupiers’ repair liabilities, I am wary of reassuring shorthand. A trader needs to understand the actual obligation, not simply be told that the auction terms offer protection.
A right still takes effort to use
There is a further distinction between having a contractual right and getting a problem resolved. A landlord may be obliged to undertake particular work, but an unanswered email does not stop a leak. Formal notices, professional advice and enforcement can take time and money. For a small occupier, the immediate loss may be damaged goods, cancelled bookings or hours spent moving equipment. The rent might be manageable while the cost of an unresolved building problem makes trading distinctly less so.
I am not suggesting that councils should guarantee every auction tenancy or take on the landlord’s bills. That would confuse responsibility and create another burden for already stretched property teams. I do think there is a case for a modest, planned check after occupation: has possession actually been given, are the agreed arrangements operating, and does each party know whom to contact? That is different from providing a continuing management service. It also gives the authority some evidence about what its intervention has achieved.
When I discuss leases with students, I keep returning to the distance between a clause and an action. The document allocates responsibility; people still have to carry it out. High street rental auctions deserve to be judged beyond the moment a bid is accepted, without being blamed for every later difficulty. My test would include something quite unremarkable: when the first ordinary property problem arises, can this occupier get a clear answer from the person responsible? That is part of bringing a shop back into use.
Need advice on a lease renewal, rent review or dilapidations claim? chris@mcgarrigle.com